Supreme Court begins hearing appeal over €850m Apple Data Centre

The law was “radically misapplied” by An Bord Pleanála in the way it granted permission for the first phase of tech giant Apple’s planned €850m data centre in Athenry, Co Galway, the Supreme Court has heard.

Supreme Court begins hearing appeal over €850m Apple Data Centre

By Ann O'Loughlin

The law was “radically misapplied” by An Bord Pleanála in the way it granted permission for the first phase of tech giant Apple’s planned €850m data centre in Athenry, Co Galway, the Supreme Court has heard.

The Board cannot permit a “salami-style slicing and dicing” of major projects so as to avoid “hard questions” and a “genuine” environmental impact assessment of those, particularly the impact of their energy demands, Michael McDowell SC argued.

While Apple has since decided not to proceed with the Athenry centre, a five-judge Supreme Court today began hearing an appeal by two objectors addressing a range of legal issues arising from how the Board dealt with the company’s proposal.

The court's decision is expected to impact on how the Board deals with similar projects.

The appeal is by Sinead Fitzpatrick, who lives close to the planned development, and Allan Daly, of Athenry.

It is opposed by the Board and the State but Apple is not involved.

The Supreme Court is considering a range of issues arising from the High Court’s rejection of the objectors' case.

It will consider whether a point of law arises concerning the application of broad general principles of EU law in particular cases and, if so, whether it should refer issues to the Court of Justice of the EU.

The central issue concerns the manner in which the Board was required by law to have regard to the potential expansion of the data centre project from one data hall to the possible construction of a total of eight data halls.

The objectors have claimed eight data halls would increase the total demand on the national grid by between 6% and 8% and the overall grid connection planned at Athenry would have a footprint equal to Dundrum town centre.

In submissions, their counsel, Mr McDowell, said, despite accepting its own inspector’s report the data centre would be unsuitable for the Athenry site unless all eight proposed data halls were built, the Board conducted an environmental impact assessment (EIA) for just one hall, not eight.

Without assessing whether this was a sustainable development from an energy point of view, the inspector took the view the employment considerations outweighed whatever doubt exists on the energy front, he said.

The government has set no national guidelines in relation to sustainable energy requirements, he noted.

The court was told the Industrial Development Authority had claimed about 300 construction workers would be engaged on the project and it would involve total investment of about €850m over the estimated 15 years it would take to build all eight data halls.

If jobs are to be weighed against energy issues, there must be an effort to balance out the two and there was no such effort here, Mr McDowell argued.

While Apple had said the centre would be powered by 100% renewable energy, the inspector had concluded the best that could be secured was average renewability figures over the 15 years.

The issue remains relevant for reasons the Sustainable Energy Authority says we must reduce energy consumption and other data centre developments are proposed, he added.

The appeal continues.

more courts articles

Newcastle United co-owner faces paying £3.4m to Greek businessman Newcastle United co-owner faces paying £3.4m to Greek businessman
Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother
Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van

More in this section

FILE PHOTO The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission has cleared the purchase of Goodbody Stockbrokers by AIB END Goodbody Stockbrokers fined over €1.2m by Central Bank over rules breaches
Nottingham City Centre Stock Irish staff at the Body Shop wait for wages as retailer shuts stores in the Republic
Ryanair comments on Norwegian Ryanair boss O'Leary's spat with Transport Minister over Dublin Airport escalates
IE logo
Devices


UNLIMITED ACCESS TO THE IRISH EXAMINER FOR TEAMS AND ORGANISATIONS
FIND OUT MORE

The Business Hub
Newsletter

News and analysis on business, money and jobs from Munster and beyond by our expert team of business writers.

Sign up
ie logo
Puzzles Logo

Play digital puzzles like crosswords, sudoku and a variety of word games including the popular Word Wheel

Lunchtime News
Newsletter

Keep up with the stories of the day with our lunchtime news wrap.

Sign up
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited